CMS has finalized its home health rule for 2027, which expands CMS’ control of Medicare enrollment and its ability to recover money paid in error, and the changes could have a significant effect on hospices. The goal is to cut fraud. Providers still don’t know which staffing setups, reporting slips or local market patterns will get them a second look, and hospices that play by the rules have to keep caring for patients while they work that out.
CMS Has More Say Over Enrollment, but Some Terms Still Need Explaining
CMS now has more authority to collect money back when a supplier or provider has had Medicare enrollment revoked. Before the rule, CMS could collect those earlier payments only in certain circumstances. CMS also has more room to revoke enrollment over what CMS considers a potentially higher risk of fraud, which could include places where suppliers and providers are grouped in unusually large numbers.
Laura Mosby, who oversees ethics and compliance at Empath Health, said enrollment oversight and getting payments back are the changes that matter most for hospices. CMS is giving itself more ways to address abuse, fraud and waste, Mosby said, so providers will need to spend more time making sure records are accurate and checking regularly on what the regulations call for. Mosby also pointed to the possibility that providers could fail to send in every required report by the deadline. Hospices will have an easier time making the adjustments if hospices focus on quality, maintain strong compliance practices and operate ethically, Mosby said.
Howard Young, a partner at Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP, said there is still an important question to answer. CMS has not said how CMS defines activity that is risky or suspicious, or what counts as fraud. The public asked CMS for definitions that were clearer and factors that were more specific. CMS did not provide those details. Young said CMS wants broad discretion over how CMS uses its authority, and that leaves hospices without a clear way to judge whether their practices meet the requirements.
The lack of clarity reaches beyond paperwork and into the money providers receive, because CMS now has more authority to recover payments.
An enrollment decision could put money a provider has already received at risk. There is a clear reason to reduce fraud. But legitimate hospices may have trouble figuring out when a routine operating practice might draw regulators’ concern if the standards do not spell that out.
When a hospice seeks enrollment, CMS can reject the application because of a medical director’s affiliations if CMS questions whether the medical director can do the job’s required work. CMS did not limit how many hospices a medical director can serve. An administrator’s distance from the area the hospice serves can also be grounds for denying enrollment, and CMS did not establish a mileage limit. A provider seeking to return to Medicare following revocation must first undergo another state survey or secure accreditation before Medicare reactivation can happen.
The provisions reach several stages of Medicare participation for providers, rather than a single enrollment decision. They address entering Medicare, having enrollment taken away, paying money back and returning to Medicare following revocation. Suppliers, as well as providers, can face repayment demands after their enrollment is revoked. Under the provisions about potentially higher fraud risk, CMS can also take away the enrollment of hospices and other types of providers, and may look more closely at places where unusually large numbers of providers are concentrated.
Rural Hospices Face Questions About Staffing Under New Rules
CMS can now deny a hospice’s Medicare enrollment if its medical director or administrator works for many hospices or works a long way from the area the hospice serves. Young said that could make things considerably harder for rural providers and organizations looking to grow throughout the areas they serve. Hospices should look more carefully at a prospective medical director’s or administrator’s ties to other organizations, Young said. Those ties could put enrollment at risk, including for a hospice looking to grow by expanding its own operations.
Katie Wehri said hospices need to account for the changes in how they hire people and check compliance; she is vice president overseeing regulatory affairs, quality and compliance at the National Alliance for Care at Home. Administrators and medical directors can still work for more than one hospice. What raises concern is whether CMS believes those people can actually perform the duties their jobs require.
Wehri said the staffing provision applies only to enrollment denials, and does not cover existing staffing arrangements at hospices already enrolled. CMS also left out a cap on how many hospices someone could be affiliated with and did not set a limit on distance, according to Wehri. That leaves a question open for rural hospice care. Staffing that helps a hospice cover a wide area could also prompt CMS to question whether the people leading that hospice can carry out their responsibilities. The distinction CMS draws could have consequences for legitimate providers looking to expand access, although the rule by itself does not establish what patients would experience.
Wehri said an administrative error, or a disclosure submitted late or not submitted at all, could draw legitimate hospices into fraud enforcement. CMS turned down requests for definitions of key terms and materiality thresholds, and also declined to give providers an opportunity to fix problems or roll out the changes gradually.
Providers need guidance that is clearer and additional time to learn the requirements and change their policies, Wehri said. Wehri also called for enforcement that is more targeted and driven by data, which gets back to the still-unanswered question of how CMS will tell fraud apart from errors by providers trying to act in good faith.
Another Step Is Needed Before Returning to Medicare
Katy Barnett said Medicare providers face more regulatory risk across the board; Barnett directs policy and operations for home care and for hospice at LeadingAge, which represents nonprofit providers of aging services. Barnett said the concerns go beyond having an enrollment application denied and include the possibility of revocation, and affect providers of hospice care, home health services and skilled nursing. When a provider’s enrollment is revoked, the provider now needs a new accreditation or state survey before Medicare can reactivate the enrollment. Providers returning to Medicare have another requirement to meet. Barnett’s advice to hospices is to read the enrollment provisions closely and build a routine for checking and updating enrollment records.
With CMS authority expanding significantly, keeping that information accurate and current is key, Barnett said. Stronger tools against fraud and improper payments could help the system.
The open question is how many honest providers get caught up along the way. CMS hasn’t said how it will use these powers, so hospices are left guessing whether their reporting or staffing could cost them enrollment.
Questions on Medicare Enrollment Changes
Which providers are affected by the enrollment changes?
Hospices are affected, and so are other providers participating in Medicare. Barnett said home health providers and skilled nursing providers also face greater risks of having enrollment denied or revoked.
Did CMS set limits on the number of hospices an administrator or medical director can serve, or the distance involved?
No. CMS set no cap on the number of hospices and no mileage limit. What CMS can do is deny enrollment when it doubts that an administrator or medical director can handle the job. The provision covers denials, not existing staffing arrangements at hospices that already have Medicare enrollment.
What do providers need to obtain after revocation before Medicare enrollment can be reactivated?
Providers whose enrollment has been revoked need to obtain a new survey from the state or accreditation before Medicare enrollment can be reactivated. The finalized 2027 rule for home health requires that step.
